GMD perspective: The quest to improve the evaluation of groundwater representation in continental- to global-scale models - INSU - Institut national des sciences de l'Univers Access content directly
Journal Articles Geoscientific Model Development Year : 2021

GMD perspective: The quest to improve the evaluation of groundwater representation in continental- to global-scale models

Tom Gleeson
  • Function : Author
Thorsten Wagener
  • Function : Author
Petra Döll
  • Function : Author
Samuel C. Zipper
  • Function : Author
Charles West
  • Function : Author
Yoshihide Wada
  • Function : Author
Richard Taylor
  • Function : Author
Bridget Scanlon
  • Function : Author
Rafael Rosolem
  • Function : Author
Shams Rahman
  • Function : Author
Nurudeen Oshinlaja
  • Function : Author
Reed Maxwell
  • Function : Author
Min-Hui Lo
  • Function : Author
Hyungjun Kim
  • Function : Author
Mary Hill
  • Function : Author
Andreas Hartmann
  • Function : Author
Graham Fogg
  • Function : Author
James S. Famiglietti
  • Function : Author
Inge de Graaf
  • Function : Author
Mark Cuthbert
  • Function : Author
Laura Condon
  • Function : Author
Etienne Bresciani
  • Function : Author
Marc F. P. Bierkens
  • Function : Author

Abstract

Continental- to global-scale hydrologic and land surface models increasingly include representations of the groundwater system. Such large-scale models are essential for examining, communicating, and understanding the dynamic interactions between the Earth system above and below the land surface as well as the opportunities and limits of groundwater resources. We argue that both large-scale and regional-scale groundwater models have utility, strengths, and limitations, so continued modeling at both scales is essential and mutually beneficial. A crucial quest is how to evaluate the realism, capabilities, and performance of large-scale groundwater models given their modeling purpose of addressing large-scale science or sustainability questions as well as limitations in data availability and commensurability. Evaluation should identify if, when, or where large-scale models achieve their purpose or where opportunities for improvements exist so that such models better achieve their purpose. We suggest that reproducing the spatiotemporal details of regional-scale models and matching local data are not relevant goals. Instead, it is important to decide on reasonable model expectations regarding when a large-scale model is performing "well enough" in the context of its specific purpose. The decision of reasonable expectations is necessarily subjective even if the evaluation criteria are quantitative. Our objective is to provide recommendations for improving the evaluation of groundwater representation in continental- to global-scale models. We describe current modeling strategies and evaluation practices, and we subsequently discuss the value of three evaluation strategies: (1) comparing model outputs with available observations of groundwater levels or other state or flux variables (observation-based evaluation), (2) comparing several models with each other with or without reference to actual observations (model-based evaluation), and (3) comparing model behavior with expert expectations of hydrologic behaviors in particular regions or at particular times (expert-based evaluation). Based on evolving practices in model evaluation as well as innovations in observations, machine learning, and expert elicitation, we argue that combining observation-, model-, and expert-based model evaluation approaches, while accounting for commensurability issues, may significantly improve the realism of groundwater representation in large-scale models, thus advancing our ability for quantification, understanding, and prediction of crucial Earth science and sustainability problems. We encourage greater community-level communication and cooperation on this quest, including among global hydrology and land surface modelers, local to regional hydrogeologists, and hydrologists focused on model development and evaluation.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
gmd-14-7545-2021.pdf (311.1 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origin : Publisher files allowed on an open archive

Dates and versions

insu-03746424 , version 1 (05-08-2022)

Licence

Attribution

Identifiers

Cite

Tom Gleeson, Thorsten Wagener, Petra Döll, Samuel C. Zipper, Charles West, et al.. GMD perspective: The quest to improve the evaluation of groundwater representation in continental- to global-scale models. Geoscientific Model Development, 2021, 14, pp.7545-7571. ⟨10.5194/gmd-14-7545-2021⟩. ⟨insu-03746424⟩
9 View
85 Download

Altmetric

Share

Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More